Skip to main content

The 10 Best Cottages in Put-in-Bay, USA

Check out our selection of great cottages in Put-in-Bay

Filter by:


Review Score

Wonderful: 9+ Very Good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our top picks Lowest Price First Star rating and price Top reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

Located 23 km from Sandusky, Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #207 offers accommodation in Put-in-Bay. Guests benefit from terrace.

The kitchen features a dishwasher. Towels and bed linen are offered in this holiday home. There is a private bathroom with a bath or shower.

It was well taken care of, had a good supply of essentials, and it was nicely decorated. We were also expressed with the well stocked kitchen. We have stayed in a few of the condos but the kitchen was never this well stocked. You can tell that the owner cares and it was greatly appreciated.

Show more Show less
9.2
Wonderful
6 reviews
Price from
$468
per night

Located 23 km from Sandusky, Put-in-Bay Poolview Condo #7 offers accommodation in Put-in-Bay. The air-conditioned unit is 49 km from Leamington.

An oven and a microwave can be found in the kitchen and there is a private bathroom. A flat-screen TV with satellite channels is featured.

Show more Show less
9
Wonderful
5 reviews
Price from
$204.75
per night

Boasting a garden, an outdoor pool and city views, Aunt Jane's Yellow House is situated in Put-in-Bay. The air-conditioned accommodation is 1.3 km from Perry s Cave. There is a sun terrace and guests can make use of free WiFi and free private parking.

Very close to middle of town. Very clean. The house is old but quaint.. Loved it!!

Show more Show less
8.8
Excellent
5 reviews
Price from
$383
per night

The spacious holiday home has 5 separate bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen with a dining area and dishwasher, and a living room with a flat-screen TV. Guests can take in the ambience of the surroundings from an outdoor dining area or keep themselves warm by the fireplace on colder days.

Location was great! We Will be coming back.

Show more Show less
8.1
Very Good
10 reviews
Price from
$245
per night

Set in Put-in-Bay, within 1.8 km of Perry s Cave, Island Club #93 offers accommodation with air conditioning.

With free WiFi, this holiday home offers a satellite flat-screen TV, a washing machine and a fully equipped kitchen with an oven and microwave. The accommodation is non-smoking.

I likes that the cabin had a grill, pool area and quiet hours. When you needed anything or had questions the staff always responded right away. Great staff on the camp ground

Show more Show less
8.5
Very Good
6 reviews
Price from
$204.75
per night

Featuring a terrace, Island Club #71 is a holiday home, set in Put-in-Bay. The air-conditioned unit is 23 km from Sandusky.

The kitchen is equipped with an oven, a microwave and a toaster and there is a private bathroom. A flat-screen TV with satellite channels is provided.

There was no breakfast. And location was fine. Was a nail sticking out of the steps going on to the front porch yards could have been a touch cleaner picked up better to make more presentable

Show more Show less
8.2
Very Good
8 reviews
Price from
$204.75
per night

Set in Put-in-Bay, within 1.7 km of Perry s Cave, Island Club #53 offers accommodation with air conditioning.

With free WiFi, this holiday home offers a satellite flat-screen TV, a washing machine and a fully equipped kitchen with an oven and microwave. The accommodation is non-smoking.

Awesome place to stay. Great taxi drivers. House was great. Pictures are accurate!

Show more Show less
8.9
Excellent
7 reviews
Price from
$204.75
per night

Set in Put-in-Bay, within 1.7 km of Perry s Cave, Put in Bay Island Club 61 offers accommodation with air conditioning.

With free WiFi, this holiday home offers a satellite flat-screen TV, a washing machine and a fully equipped kitchen with an oven and microwave.

Show more Show less
5
Review score
1 reviews
Price from
$263.25
per night

All Star Ohio House is located in Put-in-Bay and offers a bar. The property is non-smoking and is set 1.3 km from Perry s Cave.

The holiday home also offers an outdoor swimming pool and a hot tub for guests to relax in. The holiday home has a picnic area where you can spend a day out in the open.

This is to all people who want to thinking rent this house . I was in put in bay area around 11:30pm with 5 month baby . I don't find any hotel in that area, And i book this so called house. I call the property to get directions but the dude who received my call told me he is a driver he don’t know anything,need to call resort to get a pin and conformation. I told him that i have both information with me in my email. He hang up his phone and never received phone again.

Show more Show less
5.3
Review score
6 reviews
Price from
$800
per night

Set in Put-in-Bay in the Ohio region, Cozy Middle Bass Cabin with Grill and Lagoon Access! has a patio. Free WiFi is available throughout the property and Middle Bass Island is 500 metres away.

The air-conditioned holiday home is composed of 2 separate bedrooms, a fully equipped kitchen with an oven and a microwave, and 1 bathroom. Towels and bed linen are offered in the holiday home. For added privacy, the accommodation features a private entrance.

The staff was nice and friendly

Show more Show less
6.5
Review score
8 reviews
Price from
$195
per night

Looking for a cottage?

Cottages are perfect for travelers who enjoy feeling cozy and independent in the countryside. Usually small, traditionally built houses, cottages are spread across one or two floors – making them great for families or vacations with a little more privacy.
Search cottages in Put-in-Bay

Most booked cottages in Put-in-Bay this month

Enjoy breakfast in Put-in-Bay!

  • Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #207
    9.2
    Scored 9.2
    Wonderful
    Rated wonderful
     · 6 reviews

    Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #207 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay, just 14 miles from Sandusky. The property features views of the lake and is 31 miles from Leamington.

  • Aunt Jane's Yellow House
    8.8
    Scored 8.8
    Excellent
    Rated excellent
     · 5 reviews

    Featuring a garden, Aunt Jane's Yellow House offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay. With city views, this accommodation features a swimming pool.

  • Aunt Jane's Two
    Breakfast options
    8.1
    Scored 8.1
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 10 reviews

    Aunt Jane's Two offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay, a 16-minute walk from Perry s Cave. Guests can benefit from a patio and a picnic area.

  • Island Club #93
    Breakfast options
    8.5
    Scored 8.5
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 6 reviews

    The air-conditioned accommodation is 1.1 miles from Perry s Cave. With free Wifi, this vacation home offers a satellite flat-screen TV, a washing machine, and a fully equipped kitchen with an oven...

  • Island Club #71
    Breakfast options
    8.2
    Scored 8.2
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 8 reviews

    Island Club #71 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay, 15 miles from Sandusky and 31 miles from Leamington. The kitchen is equipped with an oven, a microwave and a toaster, as well as a coffee machine.

  • Put in Bay Island Club 61
    5.0
    Scored 5.0
    Average
    Rated fair
     · 1 review

    The air-conditioned accommodation is one mile from Perry s Cave. With free Wifi, this vacation home offers a satellite flat-screen TV, a washing machine, and a fully equipped kitchen with an oven and...

  • All Star Ohio House
    5.3
    Scored 5.3
    Average
    Rated fair
     · 6 reviews

    A 15-minute walk from Perry s Cave, the vacation home offers a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a bar. The vacation home has a picnic area and a hot tub.

  • Cozy Middle Bass Cabin with Grill and Lagoon Access!
    6.5
    Scored 6.5
    Pleasant
    Rated pleasant
     · 8 reviews

    This vacation home offers accommodations with a patio. Free Wifi is available throughout the property and Middle Bass Island is a 5-minute walk away.

These cottages in Put-in-Bay have options with FREE cancellation

  • Middle Bass Island Home - Pool and Hot Tub Access!
    7.1
    Scored 7.1
    Good
    Rated good
     · 10 reviews

    Free Wifi is available throughout the property and Middle Bass Island is a 5-minute walk away.

  • Island Club #27
    Free cancellation options available
    7.7
    Scored 7.7
    Good
    Rated good
     · 4 reviews

    The air-conditioned accommodation is a 19-minute walk from Perry s Cave.

  • Put-in-Bay Poolview Condo #6
    Free cancellation options available
    6.0
    Scored 6.0
    Pleasant
    Rated pleasant
     · 1 review

    The air-conditioned accommodation is a 17-minute walk from Perry s Cave.

  • Put-in-Bay Poolview Condo #2
    Free cancellation options available
    5.5
    Scored 5.5
    Average
    Rated fair
     · 2 reviews

    The air-conditioned accommodation is a 17-minute walk from Perry s Cave.

  • Aunt Jane's Guest House
    Free cancellation options available
    3.5
    Scored 3.5
    Poor
    Rated poor
     · 2 reviews

    Providing a terrace, Aunt Jane's Guest House provides accommodations in Put-in-Bay. This property offers access to a patio, free private parking, and free Wifi.

  • Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #108
    Free cancellation options available
    8.0
    Scored 8.0
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 1 review

    Featuring air conditioning, Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #108 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay. Sandusky is 14 miles from the property.

  • Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #103
    Free cancellation options available
    8.0
    Scored 8.0
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 4 reviews

    Located 14 miles from Sandusky, Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #103 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay. The kitchen has a dishwasher and an oven, as well as a coffee machine.

  • Aunt Jane's Victorian Manor
    Free cancellation options available
    7.2
    Scored 7.2
    Good
    Rated good
     · 16 reviews

    Located in Put-in-Bay, 26 mi from Sandusky, Aunt Jane's Victorian Manor features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and free WiFi.

Traveling by car? These cottages in Put-in-Bay offer free parking!

  • Put-in-Bay Poolview Condo #7
    9.0
    Scored 9.0
    Wonderful
    Rated wonderful
     · 5 reviews

    Put-in-Bay Poolview Condo #7 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay, just 14 miles from Sandusky. An oven and a microwave are provided in the kitchen and there is a private bathroom.

  • Island Club #53
    8.9
    Scored 8.9
    Excellent
    Rated excellent
     · 7 reviews

    The air-conditioned accommodation is 1.1 miles from Perry s Cave. With free Wifi, this vacation home offers a satellite flat-screen TV, a washing machine, and a fully equipped kitchen with an oven...

  • Put in Bay Island Club 56

    The air-conditioned accommodation is 1.1 miles from Perry s Cave. With free Wifi, this vacation home features a satellite flat-screen TV, a washing machine, and a fully equipped kitchen with an oven...

  • Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #109

    Located 14 miles from Sandusky, Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #109 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay. The property is 31 miles from Leamington and features views of the lake.

  • Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #105
    8.0
    Scored 8.0
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 3 reviews

    Located 14 miles from Sandusky, Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #105 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay. It provides free private parking.

  • Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #202

    Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condo #202 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay, just 14 miles from Sandusky. The kitchen is equipped with an oven and a microwave. A TV is featured.

  • Island Club #77

    Island Club #77 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay. The kitchen has an oven and there is a private bathroom. A TV is featured.

  • Put-in-Bay Poolview Condo #8
    9.0
    Scored 9.0
    Wonderful
    Rated wonderful
     · 4 reviews

    Put-in-Bay Poolview Condo #8 offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay, 14 miles from Sandusky and 31 miles from Leamington.

FAQ about cottages in Put-in-Bay





Cottages That Guests Love in Put-in-Bay

  • 7.6
    Scored 7.6
    Good
    Rated good
     · 124 reviews
    The location of the property to downtown is great. The outdoor pool area is nice but hot tub not working. The staff members were friendly as well.
    Kimberly
    Group
  • 8.5
    Scored 8.5
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 6 reviews
    I likes that the cabin had a grill, pool area and quiet hours. When you needed anything or had questions the staff always responded right away. Great staff on the camp ground
    R
    Renee
    Group
  • 9.4
    Scored 9.4
    Wonderful
    Rated wonderful
     · 5 reviews
    Had a wonderful time. Cabin was equipped with everything we needed
    Terri
    Family with young children
  • 7.3
    Scored 7.3
    Good
    Rated good
     · 60 reviews
    Liked the decor, atmosphere /style of the cabin
    Shannon
    Family with young children
  • 8.0
    Scored 8.0
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 3 reviews
    The cabin was close to everything
    Gary
    Solo traveler
  • Avg. price/night: $177.34
    7.2
    Scored 7.2
    Good
    Rated good
     · 931 reviews
    Good hotel. Enjoyed the swim up bar and hot tub. My only complaint the last full day we were there. Housekeeping didn't make our beds. May have been because we were in our room more but if they would have asked we could have driven the golf cart around so they could have straightened up our room.
    Daniel
    Family with young children
  • Avg. price/night: $123.69
    8.5
    Scored 8.5
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 130 reviews
    We had a great time at our stay at the Bird’s Nest. The cottage atmosphere is really nice. Our room was very clean and had comfortable beds. The pool is great. We rented golf carts during our stay and they were excellent. We can’t wait to come back!
    Lee Anne
    Family with young children
  • Avg. price/night: $123.69
    8.5
    Scored 8.5
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 130 reviews
    Had a wonderful overnight stay at The Birds Nest. The cottages are so cute and the perfect size for a quick trip to the Bay! Love the close proximity to the ferry too. We will definitely be back!
    Maureen
    Group
  • Avg. price/night: $123.69
    8.5
    Scored 8.5
    Very Good
    Rated very good
     · 130 reviews
    This was a nice, quiet location, yet had a beautiful swimming pool, shelter house, and grills. This cottage style resort is located near the Miller Ferry and State Park Campground. We rented a golf cart right there and was able to get downtown easily, within a few minutes. The price was very reasonable and we would definitely return to Bird Nest Resort.
    Sherie
    Young couple